A VPN buyer asks whether the no-logs claim can be verified, how much the service costs after the promotion, how many devices a subscription covers and whether the money is refunded. These decide 50 points out of 100.
protonvpn.com · Proton AG, Proton Foundation (non-profit)
78.9SCORE
No logging100
Annual price for the extension period0
Number of devices100
Money-back period61
Basic metrics · 85.7
Digital quality77
Transparency100
Reachability55
AI quality score92
+ Very clear pricing: renewal prices are shown directly on the checkout page, and the text also states exactly what price the service renews at
Basic metrics: 85.7, rank 2 · ▲ 1 place
– Annual price in the renewal term: Prices are shown on the page only in dollars (renewal term 83.88 USD per year), so the euro amount cannot be quoted.
mullvad.net · Amagicom AB, founder-owned, no venture capitalists
70.2SCORE
No logging100
Annual price for the extension period0
Number of devices44
Money-back period18
Basic metrics · 87.9
Digital quality98
Transparency100
Reachability40
AI quality score87
+ Transparent fixed pricing without campaigns or discounts
Basic metrics: 87.9, rank 1 · ▼ 3 places
– Annual price for a renewal period: The annual price is not stated in euros, only €5 per month for all periods, and the page does not give an annual total.
surfshark.com · Cyberspace B.V. (Netherlands), same owner as NordVPN, merged in February 2022
67.5SCORE
No logging100
Annual price for the extension period0
Number of devices100
Money-back period61
Basic metrics · 62.8
Digital quality72
Transparency52
Reachability40
AI quality score72
+ Comprehensive data protection documentation: the Trust Center includes detailed descriptions of security protocols, encryption and data protection.
Basic metrics: 62.8, rank 9 · ▲ 4 places
– Annual price for the renewal period: The page does not state the annual price in euros for the renewal period, only that the price is determined upon renewal.
The buying motives of these services could not be checked; the reason is shown for each one. They are not on the list as poor performers but as unscored. The result of the basic metrics is shown for comparison.
QUESTIONCan I verify that the VPN does not store my traffic?
Whether the service provider has stated on its page that the absence of records has been checked by an external party.
Independent audit = 100, certified but the certifier not stated = 60, own promise only = 30.
20 p
Annual price for the extension period
QUESTIONHow much does a VPN cost per year once the introductory offer is over?
Annual price in euros stated on the page for the renewal term or without a campaign. Dollar prices are left out because the exchange rate is not quoted from the page.
€50 or less = 100 points, €100 or more = 0, in between directly proportional.
10 p
Number of devices
QUESTIONHow many devices can I protect with one subscription?
Maximum number of simultaneous devices. Unlimited is entered as 10.
10 devices or unlimited = 100 points, 1 device = 0, in between directly proportional.
10 p
Money-back period
QUESTIONHow long can I try it and get my money back?
Length of the money-back guarantee in days from the first purchase.
45 days or more = 100 points, 7 days or less = 0, in between directly proportional.
10 p
Basic metrics
Digital quality, transparency, reachability and AI quality score
Basic metrics × 0.5
50 p
Notes
The comparison includes nine VPN services. NordVPN blocks automatic reading, so it was not scored.
The price is included only as an annual price in euros. Proton, PIA and Windscribe show prices in dollars, so they received no price points.
Information that the page does not state is left blank and not guessed.
About this comparison
We scored 9 VPN services on 19 metrics. The key question for a service that sells privacy: does it say who owns it?
A VPN service's job is to protect your privacy, so it matters whose hands the service is in and in which country it operates. By comparing several services you can see which disclose their owner and jurisdiction openly and which do not.
What transparency means in this category
Price displayed without contact details (30), renewal price stated (not just an offer price) (20), owning company stated on the site (15), jurisdiction stated (10), logging policy stated (15), independent audit displayed (10)
How to read the comparison correctly: Half of the points come from buyer's questions, i.e. things the buyer finds out before deciding. The other half measures how openly the company publishes its prices, terms and contact details. Clear differences in points indicate a genuine difference: one tells you the price immediately, another only after logging in. Close scores should not be read as a ranking order, because every measurement has a margin of variation. The measurement accuracy and the full calculation formula are open in the methodology.
Customer experience is brought into the assessment separately. We also collect customer feedback and customer experiences about companies through separate surveys. The survey results will be added to the overall assessment later.
Five out of nine are held by two owners.Kape Technologies owns ExpressVPN, CyberGhost and Private Internet Access, three ”competitors”, one owner. NordVPN and Surfshark belong to the same Dutch Cyberspace B.V. holding company (merged 2/2022), although they operate as separate entities. For a service selling privacy, ownership is not a side issue, which is why we separately measure whether the service itself says who owns it.
These are not Finnish companies, with the exception of F-Secure (business ID (Y-tunnus) 3269349-7, Nasdaq Helsinki), which is the only Finnish one on the list. That is why, instead of the business ID (Y-tunnus), we measure jurisdiction and owner. Jurisdiction is essential for a VPN: e.g. PIA operates from the United States and Windscribe from Canada (5 Eyes countries), Proton from Switzerland and Mullvad from Sweden.
Why is Atlas VPN missing? It no longer exists: Nord Security shut down the service on 24 April 2024 and moved its customers to NordVPN. Zenmate was merged into CyberGhost in 2023. F-Secure's Freedome ended in May 2024 and is now part of the F-Secure app.
The comparison describes the transparency and technical quality of the services' websites, we do not test VPN connection speed and cannot verify logging policies. An independent audit is a metric precisely because it is the only public way to verify a promise. Some of the links may be advertising links; they do not affect the scores.
Comparison guide
What to consider in the comparison
Ownership is concentrated: Kape Technologies owns ExpressVPN, CyberGhost and Private Internet Access, three seemingly competing brands. NordVPN and Surfshark belong to the same Dutch holding company.
The jurisdiction matters: For example, the United States and Canada belong to the so-called Five Eyes countries, whereas Switzerland and Sweden do not. This may affect how authorities can demand data.
A no-logs promise is not enough on its own: every service can claim that it does not store user data. An independent third-party audit is the only public way to check whether the promise holds true.
Brands disappear: Atlas VPN was shut down on 24 April 2024 and its users were moved to NordVPN, Zenmate was merged into CyberGhost, and F-Secure's Freedome ended and is now part of the F-Secure app.
The comparison describes the transparency of websites, and we neither test connection speed nor are able to verify logging policies ourselves; we rely on public audits.
How Suomen Paras assesses and scores
Every company is measured with the same public formula: half of the points come from buyer's questions and half from basic metrics, which have four pillars: technical quality, transparency, reachability and AI quality score. Ranking cannot be bought, and you can see the origin of each point on the company's profile. Read the full methodology →
Expert tips
Before ordering, check who actually owns the VPN service. Three differently named services may belong to the same group.
Favour a service whose no-logs policy has been confirmed by a named, independent third party, not just its own marketing copy.
If privacy is the main reason for getting a VPN, find out the service's jurisdiction before ordering.
Compare the renewal price and not just the introductory price of the first subscription period, because price differences between VPN services can be large.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the ownership of a VPN service matter?
With a service that sells privacy, ownership is not a side issue. The same group can own several seemingly competing brands, in which case the choice between them does not necessarily mean different practices or different infrastructure.
What does a no-logs policy mean, and can it be trusted at face value?
A no-logs policy means that the service does not store information about the user's activity. The claim should be treated with caution unless it has been confirmed by a named, independent auditor whose report is publicly readable.
Why are Atlas VPN or Zenmate not on the list?
Neither exists any more as an independent service. Nord Security shut down Atlas VPN on 24 April 2024 and moved the users to NordVPN, and Zenmate was merged into CyberGhost in 2023.
How does Suomen Paras score VPN services?
We measure every service's public website with the same formula: whether the owner, jurisdiction and logging policy are disclosed openly, whether the no-logs policy has been verified by an independent party, and whether the site works well technically. A ranking cannot be bought, and you can see the justification for each point in the service's profile.
Are you listed and would like to rank higher?
The free pre-analysis shows every item where your company loses points and which rank fixing it is enough for. The paid analysis shows what the items are and how to fix them.
Can't find your company on the list even though it should be there? Get in touch and we will include it in the next measurement round.